What Can the Discovery of Boron Tell Us About the Scientific Realism Debate?

研究成果: Chapter同行評審

摘要

This chapter examines the work in chemistry that led to the discovery of boron and explores the implications of this episode for the scientific realism debate. This episode begins with Lavoisier’s oxygen theory of acidity and his prediction that boracic acid contains oxygen and a hypothetical, combustible substance that he called the boracic radical. The episode culminates in the work of Davy, Gay-Lussac, and Thénard, who used potassium to extract oxygen from boracic acid and thereby discovered boron. This chapter shows that Lavoisier’s theory of acidity, which was not even approximately true, exhibited novel predictive success. Selective realists attempt to accommodate such false-but-successful theories by showing that their success is due to the fact that they have approximately true parts. However, this chapter argues that this episode poses a strong challenge to selective realism because the parts of Lavoisier’s theory that are responsible for its success are not even approximately true.
原文American English
主出版物標題Contemporary Scientific Realism: The Challenge from the History of Science
編輯Timothy D. Lyons, Peter Vickers
出版地New York
發行者Oxford University Press
章節3
頁面33-55
頁數23
ISBN(列印)9780190946814
DOIs
出版狀態Published - 2021

指紋

深入研究「What Can the Discovery of Boron Tell Us About the Scientific Realism Debate?」主題。共同形成了獨特的指紋。

引用此